Things Not To Say:
1. Just look on the bright side - you have a lot to be thankful for. No shit. Really? Of course intellectually I know that I have a lot to be thankful for but depression isn't about intellectualizing - if I could talk myself out of my feelings, I would have done so a long time ago, so why not just give me a second helping of guilt by reminding me that in addition to feeling like crap, I'm ALSO not being grateful for what I have?
2. You're making yourself this way - if you just tried harder/did x differently/thought differently/believed in Jesus then it would get better. This is a fairly ignorant point of view in that it assumes the person is completely in control of the way that they feel. You know who feels the worst about my depression? I DO. If I could press a button or snap my fingers or even saw off a limb in the promise that this would disappear, I would do it in a heartbeat. It's not about mind over matter.
3. Are you sure you're able to work/parent /have more children in the state you're in? Are you me? Are you my husband? Do you have deep, intimate and personal knowledge of our lives and decision making capabilities? No? Then shut the f*ck up and stop assuming that I'm incapable of making informed decisions simply because I struggle with depression.
4. I totally know how you feel - Maybe you do, maybe you don't. Regardless I've never felt helped or commiserated with when someone told this to me. Chances are unless you've lived my exact life, you can't possibly know exactly how I feel. Maybe you're going through or have gone through something similar - in which case - let's chat!
5. How does your husband put up with you? This person was lucky I didn't punch them in the face. So there's that.
6. If you don't stop you're going to mess up your child/children - I had a psychiatrist tell me this. I'm serious. Wow. That was the last time I ever saw or spoke to her; went out and found a post partum depression SPECIALIST. Not all psychs are created equal - some of them are downright awful people with no capacity to empathize with others. It boggles the mind how they ended up in their current career, but always remember - you HAVE choices. Just because they have a Ph.D at the end of their name doesn't mean they know YOU better than YOU do!
7. Hang in there! K, thanks. I'll keep that in mind.
Things To Say:
1. How can I help?
2. I'm there for you - here is my telephone number/email/etc and I'm available to talk if you need me.
3. I don't know how you're feeling but I'm sorry that you're feeling that way because I care about you.
4. You're doing a good job by seeking help/trying hard/expressing your thoughts or feelings
5. What you're feeling is not wrong/bad/crazy
6. Your family and friends love and value you
7. You are a worthwhile person and you are not defined by your diagnosis
Oh good! I said a few of the "good" things and none of the "bad." Go me!! lol
ReplyDeleteIn all seriousness, I hope things start looking up for you soon. Such a rough place to be when everything is dreary and hopeless. *hugs*
Not to say this is an inclusive list, lol, just my personal experience! Other people may completely disagree *shug*
ReplyDeleteI have a family member who really struggles with depression and it's so hard for me to see him battle it.
ReplyDeleteThanks for providing me with some additional things I can say to help him.
Two things I like:
ReplyDelete1. when I'm depressed I have an awful time making decisions, even simple ones. I like when people will make decisions for me. I guess this requires some sensitivity as there are some times when this isn't appropriate.
2. A careful balance between taking it seriously and not taking it TOO seriously. I'm (and maybe other depressed people?) sensitive to others' reactions; if someone's reaction is "Oh my god are you going to be OK? It sounds awful!" I tend to feel worse. But of course you can't just blow it off, either.
Mostly it really helps when people remind me that they care about me and that I'm valued for more than just these awful feelings - it helps keep perspective.
ReplyDeleteAnne - I TOTALLY get the decision thing. Sometimes I need someone to take control so I don't have to think about anything else right at that moment in time, however, do it too often and it makes me feel incapable. A lot of these things are a fragile balance - I guess that's what makes it so difficult.
ReplyDeleteThis is a great list, Michele. I think a lot of people have a hard time differentiating between empathy and sympathy. Also, they often forget that if you have nothing good to say, say nothing at all. None of us can ever imagine what life is like for another person. We can only try to do our best to support them through their own experience. I love you and am always here for you anytime you need me!
ReplyDeleteI'm proud of you for writing this blog post. As someone who also struggles with depression and anxiety, I often find myself struggling with this issue as well. While I can't think of any other comments to add to the list (these are pretty spot-on!), I can empathize with you. Being told that I "should be more grateful" (which I'm told quite often) just causes me to feel guilty. Being told to exercise/eat better/socialize more/etc. just makes me feel like I'm not doing ENOUGH. The most important thing is to ignore the people who make you feel bad and to trust the ones who are there for you. The people who love you will be there through good times and bad. I'm sending a big virtual HUG. Please know I'm always here to chat if you need someone to lean on.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite is, "You are just going to have to get over it."
ReplyDeleteA simple, "I am sorry you are having a rough time now." Actual empathy. Typically that leads into a small worth while conversation or it can just be that and no more conversation.
I could write a list like this about things people say about kids with special needs ha. I swear I sent you my number before I even read this, seriously text whenever, I will listen :) I have problems with anger, I get sad too, but it's mostly my anger that I have a hard time controlling. It's so scary because this isn't who I used to be at all! I feel like no one understands.
ReplyDeleteYou guys are all awesome :) xoxo
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to say how much I love this post! I think even well meaning friends and family just don't know what to say so they end up saying hurtful or ignorant things. Sometimes people are not thoughtful before they open their mouths and then there are those who should just know better and are jerks - like the doc who said you would mess up your kids. Sigh...that's the one I would want to punch - haha! I loved your list of things people SHOULD say. Great post!
ReplyDelete